* = Estimated dates of operation
43 Steve’s Waxing Service (1947)
105 Augusta Green, Insurance (1937)
109 Sullivan Real Estate (1939)
125 Farmingdale Christian Church (1976-Present), Masonic Lodge (1921-1970)
130 Murray Tuck Insurance (1950-1964)
132 Farmingdale Family Dental (2000-Present), Irwin Markowitz, DDS (1995)
134 Sinclair Auto Electricians (1951), Du-Al Service Center (1950), Bethpage Auto Service (1935-1939)*, North Main Street Station
135 Music & Arts (2018-Present), Farmingdale Music Center (1945-2018) also known as Al LiCausi Music Center
137 Dr. Benjamin Giminaro
143-145 Farmingdale Hotel & Bar (1935-1944)*
145 Parking Lot (Present), Shamrock Pub (1993-1995)*, Farmingdale Hotel (1947-1950)*
155 Land of Oohs and Oz (1996-Present), Sobol (2018-Present), Our Neighborhood Deli (2017), Irving’s Factory (1977), Irvin’s Outlet Store (1953-1957)*, Farmingdale Auto Parts
157 Farmingdale Stationery (1993-1995)*, Farmingdale Ice Service (1936)
158 Canda Leo Furniture (1925-1968)*
169 My Grandmother’s Kitchen (2021-Present), Chichimecca’s (2012-2019), Estelle’s Contemporary Smokehouse & Bar (2011), Fatty Beltbuckles (2009-2010), Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant (2009)*, Melanie’s Bistro (2000-2001)*, Victoria Station (1995)*, Sidecar Café (1981-1995)*, Thunderbird Art Gallery (1967)*, Farmingdale-Bethpage Federal Savings & Loan (1936), Norman Sullivan Insurance (1917-1930)*
185 Vintage Wine Bar (2015-Present), Wild West Saloon (2010-2015), Inn on Main (2009), Falcon’s Nest (2000)*, Third Rail Inn (1986)*, Charlie K’s Pub (1981)*, Farmingdale RR Teen Disco (2/1979), M.S. Auto Parts (1962), Gregory Moving & Storage (1947), Central Hotel (1910)*, Noon Hotel (1860-1879)*,
186 Precision Sportsman (1995), Central Bar & Grill (1947-1970), US Post Office
187 Tiny Thai (4/2004-Present), Java Java (12/2002), Pretty New To You Thrift Store (1996-2000)*, Covent Garden (1985)
188 Dave Lifsh*tz Stationery
189 Rolling Spring Roll (2013-03/2024), Central Barber Shop (1939-1942)
190 Croxley’s (2008-Present), Downtown (2001-2005), Downtown Bar & Grill (1993-1998)* Wulf Foto (1990), Fair Department Store (1952)
191 Chiddy's Cheese Steaks (2018-Present), Munchie’s (2015-2017)*, Main Deli & Grocery (2003), Delicious Delites (12/2002), Center Stage Dance Studio (1989-1995)*
192 The Craft Spot (1973), Sandwich Shop (1972), Lee Aire Fashion (1949-1959)*, Schneidkraut Department Store (1939-1956), Kranzler’s Clothing (1891-1937)*, Nandell's Stylist
193 Creations Pizza & Yogurt (2015-2020), Alexa’s Unisex (2011), American Tae-Kwon Do Karate Academy (1990), Crown Finance (1951), Island Cleaner (1948), Village Print Shop (02/1933-1941), Gruber's Upholstery (1930), Wehrlin Sign Service (1930), Allan Finger Electrician (1925-1932)*
194 Outcast (1975), Dale Paint & Wallpaper (1961)
195 X Bar Lounge/Blue Hawaiian (2013-Present), El Pulgarcito’s (2011), La Finca (2008-2009), Annabella (1964-1993)*, Sorrento Restaurant (1961-1963)*, Main Street Library (1952-1961), Gennari Photography (1947-1948), Harmony Radio (4/1946-07/1946), Nassau Realty (11/1936-02/1937)
196 Tre Scalini (2011-Present), La Casuccia (2007-2011), Bella Fortuna (04/4004), Imperial Recording Studio (1968), Captain Andy’s (1961-2004), Farmingdale Meat Market (1936-1947), Fred Koop’s Meat Market
199-200 Henry Pape Inc. (1933-1947)*
199 Farmingdale Laundromat (2011-Present), Super Value (1990), Manny Kantos Auctioneer (1983-1988)*, Central Barber Shop (1947), Farmingdale Garage (1911-1932)*
200 Farmingdale Floor & Walls (1962-1963)*, Kagan’s Men’s Shop (02/1946-1950)*, Favorite Cleaners (1944), Bud’s Mens Shop (1941)
202-204 Peanuts (1997-2021), Sorrento Restaurant (12/1944-1954)*,
202 New Covenant Christian Book Store (1978-1996)*, Bert & Bob Shoe Store (1950), Power’s Bootery (1939-1950)*, The Bootery (1939), Grocery & Deli (7/35), Electrical Contractor (1934)
203 Jane’s Nails (1999-2015), Rose’s Nails (1995), John’s Bargain Store (1939-1954)*, Frank Schneider Retail Store (1939), Fan-Tam Department Store (05/1938)
203-205 Chloe Nail Salon (2013-Present), Jane's Nails (2015-2017), Schneidkraut Department Store (1921-1938)*
204 Jo Jo's Deli (1974-1975)*, Winkler’s Deli (09/1959), Sorrento’s (1947), Helling’s Bake Shop (1939), Lammer’s Pharmacy (1922-1937)*
205 Café Dolce Vita (2014-2015), Acupuncture (2006-2014), Tanning with a Touch of Class (2001), 99 Cent Store (1996), Thrift Shop/Animal Shelter (1977), Lee’s Beauty Shoppe (1961-1964)*
206 The Tap Room (2022-Present), That Meetball Place (2016 - 2022), Benjamin Moore Paints (2011-2015)*, Burns Security (1977-1987)*, Birthright (1974-1977)*, Norman Sullivan Insurance (1961-1966)*, Sullivan & Knobloch (10/1943-03/1948), Joseph DeMarco Architect (1939), Radio Service Laboratories (1937), Westinghouse Electric (1936), Virginia Hoffman Dance Studio (1934)
207 Barber Shop (2007), Anderson Advertising (1954), A. Rosano Grocery (1929-1939)*
208 C. O. Schmidt Hardware (Unknown address from 1918-1938. 208 Main Street from 1938-2008)
209 Steven’s Shop (1938-1950)*, Karp’s Dress Shop (1930-1936)*
209-211 Taste of Long Island (2012-2015), Bezoza's Fabric Box (1977), Budget Shop (1952)
210 Farmingdale Meat Market (1946-Present), Captain Bill’s Fish Market (-1946)
211 Flux Coffee (2017-Present), Tattoo Ritual (2011-2016), Peter’s Bicycle Center (1993-1998)*, Bezoza’s Fabric Box (1971-1984)*, Eastern Music Box Company (1963-1969), Stanley Store (11/1939-1948)*
211A Lithology Brewery (2016- Present)
212-214 Cinque Food Market /Economy Food Market (1927-1942)*
212 New Children’s Shop (11/1947-02/1963) – also listed as 210
213 Farmingdale (Gluck’s) Restaurant
215-217 Modern Art Decorators (1946-1952)*
216 W & S Pizza (1997), Domino’s Pizza (1995), Farmingdale Bootery (1977-1984)*, J & J Shoes (1977), Farmingdale Shoe Store (1950-1966)*, K & M Drugs (1943-1954)*, Koop Meat Market (1936)
217 The Republic (2011-1/15/2024), Modern Bar & Restaurant (1982-1995)*, Harry’s Modern Bar & Grill (1955-1975)*, Modern Art Decorators (1944-1950)*, Gluck’s Restaurant (1936),
218 Ira’s Mens Wear (1961), Long Island Army & Navy (1952-1954)*, Baccarella Barber Shop (06/1947-11/1955), Santini Beauty Salon (1939), Modern Shoe Repairs (1930-1932)*
218-220 Dry Goods & Apparel (1965)
219 Star's Clothing (1954), Mays (1931-1941)*
220 Jim’s Stogies (1996-Present), Play Pals Plus (1993-1996), Cheryl-Ann Shop (1975-1993)*, Children’s Shop (1955), Todd’s Fur Shop (1947-1950)*, Ritz Shoe Repair (1939)
221 Wings Over Farmingdale (2009- Present), Emil’s Salon (1983-1996)*, Little Village Fish, Meat, & Produce Market (1977), duch*ess Shops (08/1947), Bon Marche (10/1940-04/1946)
222 Allstate (2014-Present), Adventure Cycle & Sports (2011-2014), Victorian Tea Room (2008-2010), Bruce Bennett Photography (2000-2007), Safe-Way (1993), Brownie Bake Shop (1956-1964)*, Farmingdale Bakery (1942-1948), Posch’s Bakery (1936-1947)*, Barth’s Bakery (1925-1939)*,
222 Rear Vita Peel Bar (2018-Present), La Riva (2015-2017), Gilt & Glitz Spa (2015-2017)
223 Angela’s Bra Boutique (1/2023), Vinoco Global East (2017 - 2020), Allstate (2011-2015)*, Farmingdale Sea Food Co. (1963-1975)*, Bill’s Place (10/1947), Smitty’s (07/1947), Raay-Noor’s Restaurant (1/1944-10/1945), Miller’s Restaurant (1942-1943)*, Colony Restaurant (10/1940-10/1941)
225 Candy’s Jewelers (2016-Present), Fidelity (2011-2012)*, William J. Burns Detective Agency (1968-1971)*, Home Food Service (1965-1966)*, Gassert’s Gift & Luggage Shop (1956-1962)*, Greco Tailor & Cleaners (1922-1952)
225A Citizen’s Campaign for the Environment (1985- Present)
226 Moby Drugs (1935-Present), Joseph's Beauty Shoppe (1952-1959)*, Claudine Beauty Shop (1950), Scholl's Meat Market (1945), Kollner Meat Market (1932-1941)*, Ketcham Taxi Service
227 Behren’s Deli (1936), Collier’s Liquors (1969), Jean-Ann Shoppe (1939-1955)*, LILCO (1939)
228 Central Beauty & Supply (1929-1930)*
229 Ira Klein Jeweler (1928-1929), Wegener's Jewelry (1930), Barber Shop
229A Western Union
230 Alibi (2019-Present), Cork & Kerry (2018-2019), Whirlin' Disc (1975-2013), G & S Luncheonette (1961-1968)*, Rapid Cleaners (1938-1939)*, Ritz Foot Appliance (1937-1938)*, Modern Shoe Repair (1937)
231 Alleyway (Present), C. B. S. Bargain Store (1980-1988)*, New Way Shoe Shop (1936), Murray’s Malt Products (1932), Bedsaw’s Ladies Shop (1929)
232 Ascher Bailey Stationery (1959-1962)*, Slovin’s Factory Outlet (1952), Farmingdale Radio & Electric Appliance (1948), Modern Art Decorators (1945), Katcham’s Taxi Service (1939), Rapid Cleaners, Lee-Mar
234 Stuff-a-Bagel (1985-Present), Eddie’s Deli (1957-1978)*, Herman G. Gluck (1952-1954)*, Gluck & Vollner (05/1949-12/1951), Watchmaker Wayne Reed (1945-1947)*, T. F. Leonard & Co (1940), Farmingdale Post (1939), Farmingdale Underwriters (1931-1937)*
235 United Cigar (1932-1936)*, A & P Supermarket
236 AHRC (2010-Present), George’s Confectionery (1961-1963)*, Bill & George’s Confectionery (5/3/1954-2/12/1955), Pop’s Ice Cream Parlor (1947-1954)*, Wilken’s Ice Cream (1930-1949)*
237 Le Che (2019-Present), My Sweet Spot (1993-1995)*, Irvel Jewelers (1976), Forzano Jewelers (1976), Claire Studios (1963-1976)*, Kanne’s Mart (1956), Farmingdale Floor & Walls (1952-1955)*, Island Floor Covering (1950-1951)*, New Way Shoe Repair (1948-1950)*, Baccarella Barber Shop (1939)
238 Brickwell Sports (2015-Present), Pretty New Thrift Shop (2000-2011)*, Suburban Sports (1977), Kagan’s Men’s Shop (1955-1962)*, Fred Behren’s Deli (1937-1948)*, Eddie’s Deli (1947- 1957)*
239 E & J Jewelry (1984-2002)*, Medine’s Haberdashery (1951), Island Cleaners (1945-1947), Shore Cleaners (1939-1943)*, U-Need-A-Tailor (1936), Pinelawn Farm Products (1928-1929)
242 Runner’s Edge (2001-Present), D’luque’s Bakery (1995), Love to Bake Shoppe (1991-1993)*, Farmingdale Bakery (1978) Dale Patries (1972), New Farmingdale Bakery (1969), Farmingdale Beauty Shoppe (1938-1940), Dr. A. R. Cooley (1904-1936)*
244 Farmingdale Bakery (1947-1961)*, Scheuer Meat Market (1930-1939)*
245 Scrubz Body Care (2019), Apple Floor Covering (1993), Staller’s Mutual Interiors (1981-1985)*, Shane’s Circus of Values (1979)*, Bethpage Bar and Grill (1934), Smiles Stores (1927-1979)*
246 Kitzer Wm Real Estate
247-249 Luggage
247 Gessert Gift (1978), Bowling & Billiard Academy
248 Step by Step Studio (2020-Present), Checkpoint Fitbox (2020), Fancy Free (2015-2017)*, Biscuits & Baskets (2004), Aristicrafts Plus (1993-2002)*, Pretty New Thrift Shop (1984-1985)*, Magro Pharmacy (1960-1978)*, Rappaport Pharmacy (1936-1948)*, Western Union (1936), William J. Kitzer Pharmacy (1930), Glucksman Bros. Pharmacy (1906)
249 Burgerology (2021-Present), Perfect Color Tanning Salon (2002-2018)*, Kojak TV Video Service (1995), Ideal Home Appliance (1945-1957)*, Farmingdale Recreation Hall (1939), Farmingdale Billiard Academy (1932-1933)*
252 Whiskey Down Diner (2018-Present), Jade Palace (1988- 2018)*, Golden Wok (1983-1984)*, Szechuan Garden (1981), Fong’s Restaurant (04/1958-1978), Main Street Deli (1956), Mohrmann’s Deli (1950-1952)*, Delleatesen Store (1948-1950)*, Ernest Gilson; Grocer (1930-1936)*, First National Bank of Farmingdale (1907-1927), Szechuan Palace, Huie’s Garden
253 Necromantic Brewing Co. (2021-Present), Furniture Store (2012-2015), Rocky’s Bakery (1989-1993)*, The Bread Box (1983), J & L Fashions (1977), Domenic Hair Stylists (1966), Harry’s Tavern (05/1943-1950)*, Mike’s Bar & Grill (1939), Alpine Sweet Shoppe & Luncheonette (1922-1932)*
254 Walkway (2019), Victor’s Jewelry Boutique (1993-2017)*, Main Street Cobbler (1977), Bethdale Jewelers (1961-1963)*, Harry Smith Jeweler (1946-1954)*, Wegener Jewelry (1939-1943)*, Bethpage Men’s Shop (1936), Bethpage Bar & Grill (1936), Heydolph’s (1924-1930)*, Brown's Hotel (1906-1911)*,
254A Victor’s Jewelry Boutique (2006)
255 Dr. Harold Cagen, Optometrist (1943-1966), Village Shop (Apr. 1932), Dr. Stearns & Wohl, Andy’s Melodie Shop
256 Mike’s Barber Shop (1945-Present), Walter Smith Stationery (1926-1945)
257 High Tide Taco Bar (2019), La Bottega (2015-2018)*, Village Stationery (2011)
258 Smith W. Stationery (1966)
259 Westerner Restaurant
260 Bank of Farmingdale
261 Grecian Grill (2001-6/2023), Corner Café (1983-1995)*, Donut Delight (1983), Thunder Ranch Restaurant (1962), Fong’s Garden (11/1940-1958)*, Bethpage Bar & Grill (03/1937), Ketcham House
262 Bonnie Bruce Beauty Salon (1936)
266 Carman, Callahan, and Ingram (2002-Present), EAB (1975-1993)*, Long Island Real Estate Board (1961), Bank of Farmingdale (1925), Nassau House (1906)
273 High Horse Tavern (Upstairs 2022), Dark Horse Tavern (2014-Present), Schwarz Florist (1977-1996), Blimpie’s (1993-2011)*, Farmingdale Wine & Liquor (10/1935-1950)*, Farmingdale Market (Mar. 1931), Rose Liquor Store
274 Library Cafe (2000-Present), Main Street Library (1961-1994), First National Bank of Farmingdale (Unknown address from 1907-1922. 274 Main Street from 1922-1958. 170 Conklin Street from 1958-1963)
275 Natureworks Art Gallery (1995), Collections Unlimited (1975), Republic Fuel Service Company (04/1954-01/1956), Paramount (1954-1955)*, Jewl’s by Debtre
277 Thunder Ranch (1966), Farmingdale Underwriters (1948-1963)*, Central Barber Shop (1936), Schneidkraut Department Store (1922-1928)
278 Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea (1936)
279-281 Medine’s Travel (1969), Sid’s, College Cleaner
279-301 Convenience Pharmacy (1988)
279 Kumon Learning (2011-2020)*, Village Travel USA (1993-1995)*, Medine's Travel Agency (1966-1984)*, Farmingdale Record Center (1962-1975)*, Conklin TV (01/1959)
280 Carman Building (1928-Present), Norman Sullivan Insurance (1966-1971), Frank Li Causi/ Nassau Barber Shop (19390-12/1946)*, Emma Marie Beauty Salon (1931)
280A Al’s & Alsam Army & Navy (1993-1995)*
281 Divine Olive (2013-2020), Village Cleaners (1993-1995)*, College Cleaners (1950-1965)*, Farmingdale Furniture Exchange (1942), Orrie Graham’s House of Music (1941), Farmingdale Bar & Grill (1934-1936)
282 Vespa (2016-Present), Village Kitchen (2014 -2016), Bollinger’s (1998 -2012), Von Leesen’s (1939-1998),Krisch’s (10/1976), Nassau Barber Shop (1947), Bernie's Army & Navy (1940-1976)*, , Windisch’s Ice Cream Parlor (Jan. 1932-1938)*
283 Harley’s Grille (2018-Present), Sakura Hibachi (2007-2017)*, Eastern Palace (2004), Sid's Jewelers (1977-1993)*, Fred Behren’s Deli
284 Main Street Collectibles (1967-1995)*, Ude's Hobby (1962)
285 Medine Travel Agency
285-295 Launderette, Dale Paint
286 Pink Nails (1995), Just Love Discount Children’s Wear (1984), Republic Electronic Supply (1956), Farmingdale Furniture Exchange (1947)
287 Main Street Photo (1995), Negri's Camera (1971-1993)*
290 Nassau Barber (1928-1947)*
Updated 3/26/24NK
