Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (2024)

Updated: by Mindee · This post may contain affiliate links · 53 Comments

Did you know that deviled eggs are healthy? Did you also know that you can cut your work in half by using an instant pot to make them? How exciting it that! Now factor in my secret ingredient for the best-tasting appetizer, and prepare to be amazed!

Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (1)
Jump to:
  • Why choose this recipe...
  • Ingredient Notes
  • Step by Step Instructions
  • Recipe FAQs and Expert Tips
  • Related Deviled Egg Recipes
  • Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs Recipe

Why choose this recipe...

  • Easy! The best-deviled eggs are not difficult to make!
  • Unique flavor because dill pickles make everything better!
  • Elegant looking with minimal effort! You don't even need a fancy tip at the end of your piping bag to make them look good!
  • Only 1 Weight Watcher point per 2 egg halves!

Ingredient Notes

  • Dill Pickle Juice - This is the secret ingredient for these dill pickle deviled eggs!!! People always think I'm crazy, but after one bite, they're hooked! I chose dill pickle juice as opposed to sweet pickle anything because these aren't intended to have a sweet, relish-y flavor. Click here for a sweet, relish deviled eggs recipe if that's what you prefer.
  • Paprika - NO, this recipe does not call for paprika, especially not as a garnish. Paprika doesn't add flavor. When sprinkled as a garnish, the color runs, making the eggs look super gross. So just say NO to paprika!
  • Hard Boiled Eggs - Do I use fresh eggs or old eggs? Which is better for hard-boiled eggs? This is a common question! There's more info in the FAQ section below, but older eggs do peel easier, while fresh eggs make for prettier-looking deviled eggs.
  • Mayo - Real mayonnaise, not salad dressing or Greek yogurt. Real mayonnaise.
  • Mustard - The regular old yellow mustard. Nothing fancy.
Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (2)

Step by Step Instructions

  • Start by hard boiling a dozen eggs.
  • On the Stovetop: If you are boiling them in a pot of water, you can make them easier to peel by boiling the eggs with a teaspoon of baking soda in the water. Boil the eggs for 8 minutes. Then drain the boiling water and cover the eggs with ice to cool them super quick.
  • In an Instant Pot: My preferred way to make hard-boiled eggs is in my Instant Pot. Place the rack in the bottom of your Instant Pot, add 2 cups of water to the bottom, place as many eggs as you can fit or just what you need, secure the lid, pressure cook on low pressure for 7 minutes, release the steam quickly, remove the hot eggs with tongs and cool them in ice.
  • In an Air Fryer!!!: It does take 16 minutes to cook them, but still an excellent option. Follow the link for instructions.
  • Cool your hot eggs quickly by running them under cold water or placing eggs in an ice bath in a medium bowl.
  • Peel the egg shells off the cooled eggs, slice them in half, and put the yolk in a bowl.
  • Use beaters to break up the egg yolks. You can also use the back of a fork to do this. Just make sure to break up the yolks into as small of pieces as you can.
  • Beat in the mayo, mustard, garlic salt, onion salt, and.....the dill pickle juice. Did you guess the secret ingredient would be a splash of pickle juice?
  • Beat well so the mixture is a completely smooth, creamy filling.
  • I like my deviled egg mixture a little thicker because I like to pipe it into the eggs. If you want to spoon it into the egg or just like your egg filling a little bit more, then add mayo until you get the consistency you like.
  • Fill a frosting bag or a pastry bag with the egg yolk mixture and pipe it into the empty egg whites. I prefer disposable frosting bags, and I generally use tip 1M, a large star tip.
  • OR spoon the mixture into each of the white halves.
  • Garnish with green onion tips, fresh dill, or a small slice of dill pickle if desired.
Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (3)

Recipe FAQs and Expert Tips

Is it better to hard-boil fresh eggs or old eggs?

This is a very common question. People generally say old eggs are better because they are easier to peel due to the thinner layer of albumen caused by a higher PH levelin the white as the egg has aged. However, the air sac also increases in size as the egg ages, so that you may have a big dip in the bottom of the peeled egg. The yolk will have settled closer to one side of the egg instead of being in the middle as well. So if you're going for super pretty-looking eggs, you want to use fresher eggs. If you hard boil them in an instant pot, they still peel fairly easily.

Can you make deviled eggs a day ahead?

Yes, you can just make sure to store them in an airtight container like this one so that the yolk filling doesn't dry out.

How long are deviled eggs good for?

If refrigerated properly and stored in an air-tight container in a single layer, they should be good for 2-3 days.

Are deviled eggs fattening?

No, actually, they are not. If you are a Weight Watchers member, it might be helpful to know that if you use Duke's light mayo for these, then 2 deviled egg halves are only 1 point!

What goes well with deviled eggs?

Just about anything! In the spring, we have them for Easter dinner, along with ham, potatoes, and some Lemon Jello Salad. In the summer, I serve them on the side of potluck barbecue foods like Marinated Chicken and Potato Salad. Fall and winter bring all sorts of holiday gatherings, all of which I am sure these deviled eggs would be perfect for!

Have you tried this recipe? If so, leave me a rating and a comment below! And don't forget to subscribe to my newsletter to get my latest recipes sent right to your email! You can also follow me on Facebook, Pinterest, and Instagram!

Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (4)

Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs Recipe

Mindee

Did you know that deviled eggs are healthy? Did you also know that you can cut your work in half by using an instant pot to make them? How exciting it that! Now factor in my secret ingredient for the best-tasting appetizer, and prepare to be amazed!

4.92 from 24 votes

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 20 minutes mins

Cook Time 10 minutes mins

Total Time 30 minutes mins

Course Appetizer

Cuisine American

Servings 24 serving

Calories 63 kcal

Ingredients

  • 12 Large Hard-Boiled Eggs peeled and halved
  • ¼ + ⅛ Cups Mayonnaise
  • ½ Tbs. Yellow Mustard
  • teaspoon Onion Powder
  • teaspoon Garlic Salt
  • 1 ½ Tbs. Dill Pickle Juice

Instructions

  • Hardly boil 12 eggs by either boiling for 8 minutes in a pot of boiling water or...

  • Place the rack in your instant pot, add 1-2 cups water to the bottom, and place eggs on the rack. Cook on low pressure for 7 minutes. Quick, release the steam.

  • Either way, cool the hot eggs in an ice bath.

  • Peel and halve the hard-boiled eggs.

  • Put the yolks in a small mixing bowl.

  • Use hand beaters to break up the yolks.

  • Beat in the mayo, mustard, onion salt, garlic salt, and dill pickle juice. Beat until the mixture is completely smooth.

  • Put the yolk mixture into a disposable frosting bag with the desired tip (I use tip 1M) and pipe it into the egg whites. Garnish with green onion tips if desired. Refrigerate until serving.

Notes

  • I like my deviled egg filling a little thicker so that I can pipe it into the egg whites. If you want to spoon it in or just like the filling a little wetter, then add more mayo a little at a time until it reaches the consistency you like.)
  • Do I use fresh eggs or old eggs? Which is better for hard-boiled eggs? This is a common question! There's more info in the FAQ section of my post, but older eggs do peel easier, while fresh eggs make for prettier-looking deviled eggs.

Nutrition

Calories: 63kcalCarbohydrates: 0.4gProtein: 3gFat: 5gSaturated Fat: 1gPolyunsaturated Fat: 2gMonounsaturated Fat: 2gTrans Fat: 0.01gCholesterol: 95mgSodium: 83mgPotassium: 33mgFiber: 0.01gSugar: 0.3gVitamin A: 132IUVitamin C: 0.004mgCalcium: 13mgIron: 0.3mg

Keyword deviled eggs recipe, deviled eggs with pickles, dill pickle deviled eggs, healthy deviled eggs, instant pot deviled eggs

Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

More Appetizer Recipes

  • 33 Picnic Food Ideas for the Whole Family to Enjoy
  • 35 Recipes with Cashews That Are Nutty and Delicious
  • Slow Cooker Italian Mushrooms
  • Soft Caramel Popcorn Balls aka Caramel Corn

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Sue Moreland

    I used this method and it worked beautifully!!

    Reply

    • Mindee

      Hah glad it was great Sue!

      Reply

  2. Julie Nichols

    We love deviled eggs! Not into sweet but the Asian chili sauce idea sounds like one to try! We love to slice peperocinis for the top! Yummy little bite!

    Reply

  3. Amanda

    I see onion powder in the ingredients list but you mentioned onion salt a couple times. Which one is it? Thanks

    Reply

      • Sally A

        I have always used paprika and they have not run except after a long period of time . The smoked variety is delicious!

        Reply

  4. Denise

    I don't care for mayonnaise or Miracle Whip, but love deviled eggs. For years I've substituted a ranch veggie dip for the mayonnaise or Miracle Whip. The texture is the same as the standard deviled egg recipes. I love them and have received wonderful reviews from other people.

    Reply

  5. Paula

    Mindee, the trick to making the eggs pretty is to take them out of the carton and let them lie on their sides in the fridge for 24 hours (at least). This allows the yolks to center, and results in better looking deviled eggs. I hope this helps!
    Paula

    Reply

    • Mindee

      I had never heard that! I'm excited to try it! Thanks for sharing!

      Reply

  6. Linda

    I use a small cookie scoop to add the filling to the eggs. You can decorate some with a black olive slice / a green olive half, a tiny sprig of parsley, etc.

    Reply

    • Mindee

      That's a great idea!

      Reply

    • Jami

      That’s an excellent idea & am gonna try that. Thank you!

      Reply

  7. John

    Ok, I'm always hearing of all these tricks to making hard boiled eggs easier to peel. Most turn out to be a crap shoot at best. There IS one way that works 99.9% of the time and I have boiled ALOT of eggs. Simpky boil a couple inches of water in a pan with a steaming basket in it. Place eggs in basket AFTER the water is boiling (this is the key). Cover with a lid and cook for 13-14 minutes. Going from cold to hot shocks the troublesome membrane and causes it to fall from the egg when peeling. Try thus and I fuarantee you won't boil eggs any other way again. Works for soft boiled too. You're welcome!!

    Reply

    • Charline Risher

      Thanks John

      I just pour a lot of salt in the water before it boils. And the eggs easily peels.

      Reply

      • Vonabe

        1 teaspoons of cooking oil in the boiling water and the eggs slip out of the shells when peeling!

        Reply

  8. Jean Cassidy

    These are great, sometimes I'm in the mood for the pickle flavor which is a hit. Other times if I want a little sweet and hot kick, I'll use some asian sweet chili sauce. They always get rave reviews, either with the dill juice or the sweet chili sauce.

    Reply

  9. Meghan

    My favorite way to get the yolks smooth is to use a spatula and smash them through a metal sieve, instead of breaking them apart with a form. The yolks are so uniform and fluffy and the ingredients all mix in so beautifully! Try it out! 🙂

    Reply

    • julie

      Or a potato ricer

      Reply

    • Brenn

      Internet family really enjoyed these secret ingredient deviled eggs. Thanks for the recipe:)

      Reply

  10. Evelyn

    I use a little Frank's hot sauce. We like them a little spicy too. But I think I'm going to try the jalapeno juice next time. Thanks for sharing the recipe.

    Reply

    • J. R.

      Great idea!!! Thank you!!!!

      Reply

« Older Comments

Leave a Reply

Secret Ingredient Deviled Eggs (2024)

FAQs

What is deviled egg filling made of? ›

If you're looking for a classic, no-frills deviled eggs recipe this is it. The filling for Southern-style deviled eggs is nothing more than egg yolks, mayonnaise (Duke's if you can find it), mustard, and sweet pickle relish. Use a fork to mash these ingredients together until the filling is completely smooth.

What is a thickening agent for deviled eggs? ›

To thicken up runny deviled egg filling, adding in some extra egg yolks is the first easy fix to try. This method thickens up the base of the filling without altering the taste. Now for a more out-of-the-box (literally) fix, try mixing some instant mashed potatoes into your filling instead.

What is the difference between angel eggs and deviled eggs? ›

Angels eggs is another name for deviled eggs for those who don't want to associate the dish with the devil. The recipes are the same. What is deviled egg filling made of? Traditional deviled egg filling includes egg yolks, mayo, vinegar, salt, pepper, and paprika.

What can I put on deviled eggs instead of paprika? ›

Cayenne is an excellent substitute for hot paprika. It'll allow you to keep the spiciness, but it will be slightly stronger in flavor, so use half the amount. To duplicate the taste of paprika more accurately, try adding a little bit of sugar (about 1/2 teaspoon sugar to 1/2 teaspoon cayenne for 1 teaspoon paprika).

What are the ingredients for deviled? ›

If you're looking for an introduction to deviled eggs, this is the place to start: just eggs, mustard, mayonnaise, a dash of Tabasco and a festive sprinkle of paprika (or jazz things up with a garnish of chives). They are a simple and spectacular addition to a holiday table.

How to get smooth deviled egg filling? ›

The best part of deviled eggs is the creamy filling. And it's at its best when it's super smooth and free of lumps of whole egg yolk. Follow this tip: For a smooth, lump-free filling, use a fork or a potato masher to thoroughly break up the egg yolks before adding the other filling ingredients to the bowl.

How to fix too much mayo in deviled eggs vinegar? ›

Be sure to add something acidic and spicy to your filling to balance out the richness of the yolks and mayonnaise. Dijon mustard, vinegar, hot sauce, and pickle relish are all good options.

What are church lady deviled eggs? ›

Disney Springs' Chef Art Smith's Homecoming Church Lady Deviled Eggs are a Southern-inspired delight, boasting creamy yolks blended with tangy mustard, mayo, and a sprinkle of paprika, offering a nostalgic and flavorful twist on a classic appetizer.

What do Christians call deviled eggs? ›

At church functions in parts of the Southern and Midwestern United States, the terms "stuffed eggs", "salad eggs", and "dressed eggs" occur instead, to avoid reference to the word "devil". For this reason, the term "angel eggs" is also occasionally used.

Why is there a devil in deviled eggs? ›

The term likely comes from the connection between spiciness and the presumably hot temperatures in hell. Since the word "devil" does have negative connotations, though, some groups of people prefer to call the dish "stuffed eggs," "salad eggs," or "dressed eggs."

What seasoning makes eggs taste better? ›

Scrambled: Herbs and spices such as chilli, cumin, chives and tarragon work really well with scrambled eggs. A little hot sauce works a treat too! You can sprinkle your seasoning on top or stir into the egg mix so that the volatile oils release as its cooking.

What seasoning does Gordon Ramsay use for eggs? ›

Salt and pepper: Only season at the end of cooking, not before. Gordon Ramsey says this prevents watery, gray eggs. Chives: Add lovely flavor and color.

Why do people put paprika on deviled eggs? ›

People put paprika on deviled eggs as a garnish for serving. A dusting of paprika contrasts nicely with the white and yellow of the egg for visual effect and it also adds a smoky, sweet flavor to the deviled egg.

What is the inside of a deviled egg called? ›

Deviled eggs, also known as stuffed eggs, curried eggs or dressed eggs, are hard-boiled eggs that have been peeled, cut in half, and filled with the yolk, mixed with other ingredients such as mayonnaise and mustard.

What do you put in the middle of a deviled egg tray? ›

Well, deviled egg trays aren't just for deviled (or soft-boiled) eggs. The little oval depressions are perfect for holding any small, roundish finger foods that could benefit from some stability or separation on the platter. I've used mine for stuffed dates, stuffed mushrooms, and meatballs.

What makes deviled food deviled? ›

To devil means to "combine a food with various hot or spicy seasonings such as red pepper, mustard, or Tabasco sauce, thereby creating a 'deviled' dish," according to the Food Lover's Companion, the definitive guide to all things food and cooking.

Is there a substitute for mayonnaise in deviled eggs? ›

Richer than Greek yogurt, but still nice and thick, sour cream is another good mayonnaise alternative in deviled egg filling. As with Greek yogurt, opt for full-fat sour cream and add mustard gradually to avoid making the filling too tangy.

Top Articles
Mini Yorkshire Pudding Canapés - My Gorgeous Recipes
Katie's Irish Mash: A Look Inside What Katie Ate: Recipes and Other Bits and Pieces - Turntable Kitchen
English Bulldog Puppies For Sale Under 1000 In Florida
Uti Hvacr
The Definitive Great Buildings Guide - Forge Of Empires Tips
Alan Miller Jewelers Oregon Ohio
Es.cvs.com/Otchs/Devoted
How Far Is Chattanooga From Here
Jesse Mckinzie Auctioneer
United Dual Complete Providers
Hardly Antonyms
R Tiktoksweets
Es.cvs.com/Otchs/Devoted
Superhot Unblocked Games
Calmspirits Clapper
TS-Optics ToupTek Color Astro Camera 2600CP Sony IMX571 Sensor D=28.3 mm-TS2600CP
Dc Gas Login
Charter Spectrum Store
Daylight Matt And Kim Lyrics
Geometry Review Quiz 5 Answer Key
Milanka Kudel Telegram
Www.publicsurplus.com Motor Pool
Ford F-350 Models Trim Levels and Packages
Village
If you have a Keurig, then try these hot cocoa options
Red8 Data Entry Job
Colonial Executive Park - CRE Consultants
Bend Missed Connections
10 Best Quotes From Venom (2018)
Halsted Bus Tracker
Boneyard Barbers
Rock Salt Font Free by Sideshow » Font Squirrel
Roch Hodech Nissan 2023
RFK Jr., in Glendale, says he's under investigation for 'collecting a whale specimen'
Craigslist Red Wing Mn
Nacho Libre Baptized Gif
October 31St Weather
Kgirls Seattle
Enjoy4Fun Uno
Busch Gardens Wait Times
Review: T-Mobile's Unlimited 4G voor Thuis | Consumentenbond
Craigslist Florida Trucks
Lbl A-Z
At Home Hourly Pay
Unblocked Games Gun Games
Garland County Mugshots Today
From Grindr to Scruff: The best dating apps for gay, bi, and queer men in 2024
Maplestar Kemono
Pas Bcbs Prefix
Random Warzone 2 Loadout Generator
Cognitive Function Test Potomac Falls
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nathanial Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 6292

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nathanial Hackett

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: Apt. 935 264 Abshire Canyon, South Nerissachester, NM 01800

Phone: +9752624861224

Job: Forward Technology Assistant

Hobby: Listening to music, Shopping, Vacation, Baton twirling, Flower arranging, Blacksmithing, Do it yourself

Introduction: My name is Nathanial Hackett, I am a lovely, curious, smiling, lively, thoughtful, courageous, lively person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.